Buyer's guide
How to choose an SEO agency in South Africa
We're an SEO agency, so we're not neutral. This page is written to be useful anyway: the questions we'd ask if we were hiring an agency, and the cases where we'd tell you to hire someone else.
Choose an SEO agency that can show results for businesses like yours, explains what it will do in the first 90 days, reports on enquiries rather than traffic, and covers AI search as well as Google. Avoid anyone who guarantees rankings or sells links by the bundle.
Six questions to ask every agency
- Question 1
What will you do in the first 90 days?
A good answer names specific fixes and pages. A vague answer ("optimise your content") usually means a monthly report and little else.
- Question 2
Which searches will you target, and why those?
Look for searches close to a sale (a service plus a location, pricing, comparisons), checked against the real Google results, not just a volume number.
- Question 3
How will you report results?
Enquiries and non-branded clicks matter. Impressions and "visibility scores" can rise while the phone stays quiet.
- Question 4
What do AI tools say about us today, and how will you change it?
Buyers now ask ChatGPT and Google's AI Overviews who to hire. An agency should be able to show you what those answers say right now.
- Question 5
Who actually does the work?
Ask whether the person on the sales call is the person working on your account, and how much is outsourced.
- Question 6
What happens if we stop?
You should own your content, your accounts (Search Console, GA4, Google Business Profile) and your data from day one.
Red flags
- Guaranteed #1 rankings or guaranteed traffic numbers
- Packages priced by the number of backlinks
- Bulk AI-written blog posts with no editing or fact-checking
- Offers to buy, filter or incentivise Google reviews
- The agency owns your Google Business Profile or analytics accounts
- Long lock-in contracts before any results
When Heynow isn't the right choice
If any of these describe you, we'll say so on the first call.
- You need paid ads managed. We focus on organic search and AI visibility.
- You want results within a month. SEO takes months; paid search is faster.
- Your budget only covers a few hours a month. A good freelancer or a one-off audit may serve you better.
- You need a large e-commerce catalogue optimised at scale. Specialist e-commerce agencies have tooling we don't.